Nieman Home
Current Issue
Archive
Professors Corner
About Us
Nieman Reports: Nieman Foundation for Journalism at Harvard
Search
Twitter
Facebook
RSS
Summer 2009
Iran: Can Its Stories Be Told?
Introduction
By Melissa Ludtke, Editor
Treatment of Journalists
Understanding Iran: Reporters Who Do Are Exiled, Pressured or Jailed
By Iason Athanasiadis
Journalism in a Semi-Despotic Society
By Byline Withheld
Peering Inside Contemporary Iran
An Essay in Words and Photographs By Iason Athanasiadis
When Eyes Get Averted: The Consequences of Misplaced Reporting
By Roya Hakakian
Imprisoning Journalists Silences Others
By D. Parvaz
‘We Know Where You Live’
By Maziar Bahari
A Visual Witness to Iran’s Revolution
An Essay in Words and Photographs By Reza
Film in Iran: The Magazine and the Movies
By Houshang Golmakani
Women Reporters, Women’s Stories
Your Eyes Say That You Have Cried
By Masoud Behnoud
Telling the Stories of Iranian Women’s Lives
By Shahla Sherkat
Iranian Journalist: A Job With Few Options
By Roza Eftekhari
View From the West
Seven Visas = Continuity of Reporting From Iran
By Barbara Slavin
No Man’s Land Inside an Iranian Police Station
By Martha Raddatz
The Human Lessons: They Lie at the Core of Reporting in Iran
By Laura Secor
Iran: News Happens, But Fewer Journalists Are There to Report It
By Mark Seibel
When the Predictable Overtakes the
Real
News About Iran
By Scheherezade Faramarzi
The Web and Iran: Digital Dialogue
Attempting to Silence Iran’s ‘Weblogistan’
By Mohamed Abdel Dayem
Blogging in Iran
Publishing and Mapping Iran’s Weblogistan
By Melissa Ludtke
The Virtual Iran Beat
By Kelly Golnoush Niknejad
21st Century Muckrakers
Introduction
By Melissa Ludtke, Editor
The Challenges and Opportunities of 21st Century Muckraking
By Mark Feldstein
Investigating Health and Safety Issues—As Scientists Would
By Sam Roe
Rotting Meat, Security Documents, and Corporal Punishment
By Dave Savini
Mining the Coal Beat: Keeping Watch Over an ‘Outlaw’ Industry
By Ken Ward, Jr.
Reporting Time and Resources Reveal a Hidden Source of Pollution
By Abrahm Lustgarten
Pouring Meaning Into Numbers
By Blake Morrison and Brad Heath
Navigating Through the Biofuels Jungle
By Elizabeth McCarthy
Going to Where the Fish Are Disappearing
By Sven Bergman, Joachim Dyfvermark, and Fredrik Laurin
Watchdogging Public Corruption: A Newspaper Unearths Patterns of Costly Abuse
By Sandra Peddie
Filling a Local Void: J-School Students Tackle Watchdog Reporting
By Maggie Mulvihill and Joe Bergantino
Words & Reflections
Objectivity: It’s Time to Say Goodbye
By John H. McManus
Worshipping the Values of Journalism
By John Schmalzbauer
When Belief Overrides the Ethics of Journalism
By Sandi Dolbee
Religion and the Press: Always Complicated, Now Chaotic
By Mark Silk
Journalists Use Novels to Reveal What Reporting Doesn’t Say
By Matt Beynon Rees
Life Being Lived in Quintessential Irish Moments
An Essay in Words and Photographs By Rosita Boland
An Enduring Story—With Lessons for Journalists Today
By Graciela Mochkofsky
They Blog, I Blog, We All Blog
By Danny Schechter
Fortunate Son: The Life and Times of Hunter S. Thompson
By Adam Reilly
The American Homeland: Visualizing Our Sense of Security
By Nina Berman
Nieman Notes
Jobs Change or Vanish: Niemans Discover an Unanticipated Bonus in Community Work
By Jim Boyd
Curator's Corner
The Journey of the 2009 Nieman Fellows—And of the Foundation
By Bob Giles
Print
Comment
Share
Digg
Facebook
del.i.cious
reddit
Twitter
Email to a friend
A Visual Witness to Iran’s Revolution
An Essay in Words and Photographs By Reza
Iran, 1980
A demonstration marking the first anniversary of the revolution.
In the mid-1960’s, Reza Deghati taught himself the principles of photography as a 14 year old living in Tabriz, Iran. During the early 1970’s, his pictures were of rural society and architecture, which he then studied at the University of Tehran. The Islamic Revolution in 1979 shifted Reza’s focus to the city, where he covered the conflict for Agence France-Presse and Sipa Press. Reza, who uses only his first name, then photographed events in Iran for Newsweek until 1981, when he fled Iran after being forced into exile. In the nearly 30 years since then, Reza has traveled throughout the Middle East and Asia, and into Africa and Europe, and had his work published primarily in National Geographic. “I have been using my camera as a tool to bear witness,” he writes. In Afghanistan, Reza founded a nonprofit organization, Aina, through which he has supported the development of independent media and fostered cultural expression. In 2008, National Geographic’s Focal Point published “Reza War + Peace: A Photographer’s Journey,” and Reza has generously contributed photographs he took in Iran in 1979 and 1980 to our project. His words accompany the photos that follow.
Iran, 1979
Reza photographed the first massive demonstration against the shah, and in his book he describes how he came to be there with his camera.
My life was turned upside down one fall day in 1978. I was working as an architect in Tehran at the time and was in the architect’s office. Suddenly, I heard a strange, unfamiliar shout. Some angry protestors were screaming, “Marg bar shah!” (“Death to the shah!”). I went to watch from the window. Soldiers came and blocked the street from both sides.
The soldiers shot blindly into the crowd. The students could do nothing. Some died instantly, falling to the ground. Others, wounded, crawled away to protect themselves. Still others ran for shelter. Then I saw one student who was fleeing but taking pictures as he ran.
I stayed by the window for three hours, transfixed by the chaos below and in a complete state of shock. I made a decision. That night, I gave up my job. I turned in my keys to the architect’s office, and I took up my cameras, which I haven’t put down since. Instability ruled in Iran; unrest and demonstrations were occurring everywhere. At event after event, I met Don McCullin, Marc Riboud, Olivier Rebbot, and Michel Setboun, among many other photojournalists who had come to Iran from all over the world. They showed me the ropes. After a few months, my photographs started appearing in the international press.
I became a correspondent for Sipa Press and for Newsweek. I covered the revolution, the riots, the war against Iraq, the war against the Kurds. Iran was boiling. The utopian fervor of the revolution had soon given way to repression. The shah had been brought down, but the mullahs who took power crushed every form of opposition, every difference of opinion. The first victims were the former political prisoners who had fought against the shah. This carnage led me to a sad observation: Hasn’t history shown us that every revolution eats its own young?
In February 1981, I was wounded on the Iran-Iraq front by a shell blast. The Iranian government was closing down the borders. My wound served as a pretext for me to leave the country. I went overseas for medical treatment. A few days before I left, I had learned that I was a wanted man, sentenced to death because of my photographs. My journey outside my country would be a long one.
Fabric Store, Iran, 1979
For months, I had watched the black chadors take over, becoming more and more widespread in the towns and the countryside. Yet Iran has a variety of people, a multiplicity of colors and landscapes. Even though decades have passed since I last saw them, I can still recall the rural women with their colorful petticoats, which contrasted with the red of their houses, made of clay. And I can still see the vividly colored rugs and the fabrics with the elaborately worked embroidery.
When I entered this fabric shop, where the only choice lay in the weave of the material, I felt stifled and depressed. The only style available was for the chador; the only color offered was black.
During those days, I often felt that, unconsciously, the people of Iran had agreed to go into mourning.
Iran, Kurdistan, 1980
Reza met an 11-year-old boy named Peyman in Kurdistan, whose father had been killed and, as they spoke, Peyman said to him, “What else is there to say about my life, about our fate as a people who are refused an identity? What about you? You say you know a little about us through your camera lens. You say you will tell the world about us. But I have a hard time understanding how you will do this. Come, I will introduce you to my grandfather.”
Reza went to his house, where they had tea. As he writes, “I thought about the Kurdish children I had come across, their eyes full of sadness. Peyman was watching me attentively but seemed distracted. He appeared weighed down, as though he were dozens of years older. Despite their grief, his family welcomed me. After we finished tea, I left the sad warmth of their home. As I reached the corner of the street, I heard a violent blast. Then there was silence, then screams, the despair and horror of a mother whose children have just been torn from her. I turned around. In the dust of the dirt and rocks pulverized by the bomb’s impact, I saw some motionless bodies.”
Peyman, his sister and his grandfather had just been murdered—bombed by the Revolutionary Guards.
Iran, 1980: Ayatollah Khomeini
At last, I had the opportunity to photograph Ayatollah Khomeini in an intimate, private setting. This would be my chance to try to gain some understanding of this man who had become such a powerful enigma. He was sitting in a bare room, which had no past or future, no history or memory. I had time to take only three photos. Then he cut me off, saying harshly, “I’m tired.” Throughout our session, he never looked me in the eye. I had sought his gaze to silence a doubt that had lurked in me since his return to Iran a year earlier. When he arrived, a reporter had asked him what he felt about being back after 15 years of exile. His reply, “Nothing.”
He was the symbol of hope for an entire nation. We had risen up against the shah in a revolution that had erupted spontaneously throughout the country. But after my brief encounter with Khomeini, the doubt I felt gave way to the certainty that a fist was about to come down on our dreams of justice and freedom.
A year after I took this photo, I left Iran, forced into exile. Earlier I had been arrested by the shah’s secret police for being a dissident. I was imprisoned for three years and tortured for five months. Now, because of my photographs showing the repression carried out by Khomeini’s regime, I was under threat from his government and had to flee. In the years since then, I have been a nomad searching for a part of my homeland in every country I visit—a quest that is like picking up and reassembling the scattered pieces of a puzzle. My camera is always looking for the truth that often hides in the shadows of events.
Iran, Kurdistan, 1980
Kurdish house bombarded by Iranian Revolutionary Guards.
Cemetery, Iran, 1981
In writing about his journey to becoming a photographer in Iran and his departure from his country, Reza observes that “Iran had become a huge cemetery, where figures dressed in black wandered among the tombs.”
2 Responses to
A Visual Witness to Iran’s Revolution
Mahasti says:
June 25, 2009 at 12:19pm
The photo essay on Khomeini is too chilling for words.
Casey Brown-Myers says:
June 20, 2009 at 1:33am
What a fantastic essay of photos of history.
Submit a Response
Name: *
Email: *
Comment: *
Enter the words above: *
Enter the numbers you hear: *
Switch to audio
Switch to image
Contact Us
Nieman Foundation
© 2009 by the President and Fellows of Harvard College |
Privacy Statement